A light-skinned female cake maker sitting at a table with a cake and calculator, looking stressed and unsure – symbolising cake pricing mistakes.

Top Cake Pricing Mistakes – And How to Avoid Them

By Makai Cake Decorating Supplies

 

 

Pricing cakes can feel overwhelming – especially when you're just starting out.
Many beginner bakers undercharge, over-deliver, and end up exhausted and underpaid.

This blog will help you spot common pricing pitfalls and fix them fast.

 

 




1. Only Charging for Ingredients 

 

It’s a classic beginner mistake: adding up flour, sugar, eggs, butter... and that’s it. But you’re not just selling ingredients – you’re selling time, skill, and creativity.

 

✅ Solution: Always include your time, utilities, packaging, and decorations. They all count.

 

 




 2. Forgetting to Pay Yourself 

 

Would you work for free in any other job? Many new bakers feel guilty charging for their time – but your hours matter.

 

Solution: Decide on an hourly rate and factor it into your pricing. Your time is valuable.

 

 




 3. Ignoring “Small Extras” 

 

Boards, ribbon, toppers, sprinkles, fondant figures – they seem small, but they add up.

 

✅ Solution: Track every item you use. Small details = real cost.

 

 




 4. Not Using a Calculator or System

 

Guessing or copying competitors can leave you undercharging.

 

✅ Solution: Use a pricing calculator or spreadsheet.

👉 Download our free Cake Pricing Calculator Template (PDF)

 

 




 5. Undercharging “Just to Get Orders” 

 

It’s tempting to lower your prices to attract customers – but that’s not sustainable. You’ll burn out.

 

✅ Solution: Price fairly and professionally. The right customers will respect it.

 

Want a full guide on what to include in your pricing?
👉 Read: How to Price Your Cakes for Profit

 

 




 Final Thoughts 

 

Cake pricing isn’t just maths – it’s confidence. Don’t sell yourself short.

With the right mindset and tools, you can price your cakes with clarity and grow a healthy business.

 

 

 


 


Back to blog